Our blog | if/else agency

Authenticity: the new marketing KPI that will really drive brand performance in 2026

Written by Chanon Asarisi | 16/01/2026

In a landscape saturated with AI-generated content, audiences no longer respond to messages that are too polished, too clean, too optimized. They are looking for human, credible, identifiable voices—people rather than formats.
As a result, authenticity is becoming a full-fledged marketing KPI, on par with reach or conversion rate.

It influences:

  • the trust placed in a brand,

  • real engagement (comments, human conversations),

  • memorability,

  • and the ability to convert in a context of growing skepticism.

In other words: what performs in 2025 is no longer the volume of content, but perceived sincerity. Authenticity is no longer an editorial tone; it is a measurable driver of marketing performance.

In a landscape saturated with AI-generated content, audiences no longer respond to messages that are too polished, too clean, too optimized. They are looking for human, credible, identifiable voices—people rather than formats.
As a result, authenticity is becoming a full-fledged marketing KPI, on par with reach or conversion rate.

It influences:

  • the trust placed in a brand,

  • real engagement (comments, human conversations),

  • memorability,

  • and the ability to convert in a context of growing skepticism.

In other words: what performs in 2025 is no longer the volume of content, but perceived sincerity. Authenticity is no longer an editorial tone; it is a measurable driver of marketing performance.

The Trust Economy: A New Marketing Framework

The historical logic of “the more you publish, the better you perform” no longer works: volume no longer creates value—trust does.
Platforms such as LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram have adjusted their algorithms in favor of human signals: authentic interactions, personal expression, real conversations.

In this new economy:

  • recommendations, social proof, and testimonials far outperform corporate messaging,

  • embodiment (leaders, employees, internal experts) becomes a driver of credibility,

  • and trust becomes a strategic asset, measurable and directly correlated with marketing performance.

The brand alone is no longer enough: it is humans who convince.

What “Authenticity” Means in a Marketing Strategy

In a world saturated with content and dominated by AI, authenticity is no longer a style—it is a communication standard.
It is built on three pillars:

  • Consistency: real alignment between what the brand says, does, and shows. No cosmetic storytelling, but visible proof.

  • Embodiment: content carried by humans—employees, leaders, experts—who speak without excessive polish, with transparency and nuance.

  • Demonstrated values: positions, actions, and behaviors conveyed by individuals, not slogans.

Authenticity is not about “being perfect”; it is about being credible, readable, and human. These are the signals that now feed trust—and therefore performance.

The New KPIs of Authenticity

Authenticity is becoming measurable. These indicators are gradually replacing purely quantitative KPIs:

  • Human engagement rate: comments, conversations, real expressions (vs. passive likes).

  • Share of voice of employees / internal experts: volume and impact of embodied content.

  • Organic repetition: spontaneous mentions, UGC, unsolicited reshares.

  • Positive sentiment and perceived credibility: tone of interactions, expressed trust.

  • Audience loyalty: recurring engagement, people commenting multiple times, long-term followership.

Today, it is these human signals—not simple reach—that truly predict marketing performance.

Why Authenticity Performs Better Than “Optimized” Content

The massive arrival of AI in marketing has turned content creation into a fast, productive… but terribly uniform machine. LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram feeds are now filled with calibrated, clean, interchangeable messages. And that is precisely what causes audiences to disengage: everything looks the same.

In this context, buyers of all generations respond more strongly to content that genuinely seems to come from an identifiable person. An opinion, a story, a face, a stance—these are what capture attention. It is not editorial perfection that creates trust, but singularity.

Studies confirm it: individuals place more trust in an expert, an employee, or a leader than in purely institutional communication. Human expression triggers more engagement, more reactions, and more conversions. Authenticity is not a style; it is a cognitive shortcut to credibility.

And this credibility has a direct impact on business. Embodied content reassures faster, reduces friction, accelerates decision-making, and mechanically lowers acquisition costs. Where a corporate message has to convince, an authentic message simply inspires trust—and receives trust in return.

In short, it is no longer the most optimized content that wins, but the one that feels the most real. Marketing is becoming what it should never have stopped being: a human conversation.

How to Embody Authenticity

Authenticity cannot be declared; it must be shown. And the most effective way to achieve this is to let those who truly bring the brand to life speak: internal experts, employees, people who see the field, the product, the customers. Their voice has a strength that marketing cannot artificially manufacture. When an engineer, a CSM, or a leader shares a reflection, a lesson, or a simple experience, the audience immediately perceives it as legitimate.

This also means accepting to show what happens behind the scenes: processes, trials, failures, moments of truth. Nothing creates more proximity than content that reveals reality, without overproduction or forced storytelling. Audiences want to understand how things are really done, not just see the perfectly polished final result.

Taking a clear point of view is just as essential. The brands that gain credibility in 2025 are not those that try to please everyone, but those that cultivate a recognizable, assumed, sometimes sharp voice. A brand voice only has value if it is embodied in consistent positions.

In terms of formats, the era of ultra-scripted videos and corporate posts is over. Spontaneous content, phone-recorded messages, comment exchanges, or direct replies perform better than any overproduced campaign. Authenticity plays out in these micro conversational moments that show a brand can speak like a person.

Ultimately, embodying authenticity means reducing the distance between the company and those who follow it. Less corporate, more conversation. Fewer “official” messages, more human voices. This is where trust is built—and today, this capital is what makes the difference.

How to Measure the Performance of an Authentic Strategy

To measure the effectiveness of a marketing strategy based on authenticity, it is no longer enough to look at likes or raw reach: these indicators mainly reflect exposure, not relationship. What matters now is real engagement—comments that open discussions, replies, opinionated shares—in short, anything that shows the audience is interacting with intention rather than reflex. The quality of these interactions says far more than their quantity.

Another powerful signal is the evolution of brand sentiment. Authenticity generally leads to an increase in organic mentions: spontaneous citations, recommendations, discussions that arise without being triggered by a campaign. When these signals multiply, it is proof that the brand is settling into conversations rather than trying to force them.

One can also observe the impact on community growth. An audience that grows naturally, without massive or artificial campaigns, is often the direct result of a sincere and identifiable discourse. People do not follow a brand for its marketing; they follow it for its perceived value and the coherence of its voice.

Authenticity is also measured in conversion, notably through the effect of social proof. Prospects who arrive “by recommendation,” messages such as “I saw your content and I want to know more,” or an increase in the “traffic vs. qualified leads” ratio are all concrete signals that the relationship built on social platforms influences purchase decisions.

Finally, a strong indicator is the dynamic of Employee Advocacy. When employees voluntarily share content, when their posts generate more interactions than those of the brand, or when their influence grows around the company’s key topics, it is usually a sign that an authentic strategy is working. Human voices then become a natural—and measurable—amplifier of overall brand credibility.

Authenticity Is No Longer an Option, It Is a Competitive Advantage

In a period where AI produces content at an unprecedented speed, everything ends up looking the same. Words, formats, and narratives become interchangeable. What makes the difference today is no longer the quantity of content published, but a brand’s ability to sound right. Authenticity becomes a competitive advantage because it immediately creates distinction: it gives a recognizable voice, an identity, a depth where most broadcast smooth, standardized messages.

This authenticity does not only improve perception; it strengthens trust, accelerates conversion, and creates more durable loyalty than any automation mechanism. When a brand speaks truthfully, the audience feels it; when it embraces its values and contradictions, it becomes credible; when it shows itself as human, it becomes memorable.

The brands that will dominate in 2025 will not be those that publish the most, but those that dare to be themselves, that clearly embody their vision, and that accept imperfection as a strength. They are the ones who understand that performance is no longer only a matter of KPIs… but a matter of relationship and of demonstrating expertise—on HubSpot, for example.